Could this be discrimination or could there be genuine business reasons?
There are so many different reasons for being rejected. Unless you get some comprehensive feedback (which is rare these days!) you won’t know the real reasons. I’ve interviewed over ten thousand candidates during my recruitment career and I’ve rejected some good candidates. Have you ever been told you are too senior or overqualified for a job?
You might wonder why being too senior or overqualified is a problem. It’s easy to jump to certain conclusions and feel disappointed. You may even feel discriminated against. Also easy to think that having too much experience is a good thing for any organisation.
For some businesses bringing more experience to the role is a good thing. These organisations can manage these individuals. Some organisations can manage career ambitious individuals and their aspirations. Forward-thinking businesses will know the advantages of future-proofing their organisation.
Some smaller businesses may see the benefits of bringing on-board someone with lots of experience. Smaller businesses typically have fewer resources and people. So, hiring someone who could take on more tasks would be an advantage. Although, they could be concerned that hiring someone more than capable of the job will be risky. Their concerns will be that you won’t stay when the jobs market picks up again.
Internal Team
Every single time the hiring manager recruits, they need to review the structure of their existing team. Good managers know their people and their strengths. They also know what skills or knowledge are needed in the future. Therefore, every time they have the opportunity to recruit they will look at what’s needed and possibly missing.
This means it’s not necessarily the amount of experience or the number of years. It’s the nature and type of experience, skills, and knowledge. It’s not just about the role in isolation. Good managers are thinking ahead to the future needs and most definitely taking into consideration the existing team.
Ageism
Unfortunately, this is a real possibility that it may be discrimination. If this is the reason for the rejection its direct discrimination. Look around the department or company and see if there are some common themes with the types of people that work for this organisation.
Despite being unlawful decision making, I’ve seen evidence of discrimination throughout my career. Probably due to a number of reasons, insecure managers, bullying style of leadership, ignorance, lack of education and training. These types of aggressive managers often unfortunately get results. However, looking at the bigger picture the advantages of building a diverse team far exceed less diverse teams. Diverse teams bring wide and varied experiences, knowledge, skills and different ways of thinking through problems.
“We have taken, and will continue to take, robust enforcement action, using all of our statutory powers, to tackle unlawful discrimination and ensure that no-one is excluded from the workplace. This includes enabling Britain’s employers to benefit from the talent and contributions of workers of all ages.” a spokesperson told People Management.
A threat to the manager
This is another potential issue that could get an overqualified candidate rejected. It’s not always the case and it’s a mistake to assume it is. I’ve worked with some very good hiring managers who wouldn’t be threatened by someone with more experience. Good managers need to be thinking ahead about succession plans and having people in the team ready to step up.
There are some situations where it wouldn’t work if someone was highly experienced and equally ambitious. A small to medium-sized business might not be able to satisfy those people’s aspirations. All this, of course, should be assessed during the interview stage not just assumed!
Managing your career expectations
There have been times where it’s clear the candidate is desperate to get any job. This really won’t work long term. It typically happens when there’s a downturn in the jobs market. When there are lots of redundancies, lots of candidates on the market and fewer jobs.
We understand you need a job and an income. However, from a purely business point of view taking on someone with more experience, skills, and knowledge for that role, could give the company a potential problem in the future.
It’s again a misconception that having more than the job requires is always a good thing. Not in every case, unfortunately. The company probably has people doing the next level of the job. It could create problems with a potentially top-heavy team with everyone wanting the next promotion. Not an easy situation to be in for a manager. In fact, it’s very challenging managing a highly ambitious team. There just isn’t the number of promotions available to the team even if they are ready for the next move. If a company cannot satisfy an individual’s career aspirations they may leave. If you are highly ambitious you’ll seek a promotion externally.
So, with all these points in mind think carefully before taking rejection personally. There could be so many business reasons for being rejected. How you handle rejection will demonstrate your character. Being rejected doesn’t mean that you are a bad candidate. It doesn’t necessarily mean you did anything wrong during the interview. Be positive and keep the door open!
- 5 Essential actions to take with your job search – even in a recession - 8th April 2020
- How to prepare for a video interview - 3rd April 2020
- 10 Practical ways to reduce the cost of hiring - 28th December 2019
- 4 tips for looking your best at your work Christmas party - 27th November 2019
- 5 Tips for Handling a tough job interview - 31st October 2019
- How to network on LinkedIn? - 13th September 2019
- What’s the purpose of a SWOT analysis? - 12th August 2019
- How to cheat the Applicant Tracking System - 7th July 2019
- Why do interviewers ask these questions? - 6th July 2019
- How do you tailor a CV? - 9th June 2019
Hello,
I was working as a Supervisor with over 15 year experience working in laboratories, plus l achieved a degree and a Masters degree. However l saw a post that there was a post of a Laboratory Technician but offering a pay rate that was 40% higher then what l was on, 15 minutes closer to home and far better benefits. I was invited for an interview to which the hiring manager was a recently appointed Laboratory Manager. I thought l had a great interview, didn’t stumbled once and l was confident throughout. However l was unsuccessful with my application and the feedback l received was ” ….the role was a backward step in my career”???????. This is a load of nonsense, never heard such a crass reason for not appointing an applicant. I came to apply for a job not to get “careers advice!!!!!!” I personally believed she was afraid of me. In the end 4 months later the company l was originally working for closed down. So much for “….backward step in my career.”!!!!!!!
Hi Fred,
Thank you for sharing your experience. I’m sorry you’ve had this negative experience. Try to put this experience behind you now and look forward to the future. With 15 years of experience in one sector, you’ll have lots to share with the next employer. Write down all your strengths including your skills, knowledge and your competencies.
I’ve just written this blog for The PD Cafe that you may find interesting: https://thepdcafe.com/why-a-growth-mindset-can-help-you-land-that-job/
Best wishes for your future.
Your Interview Coach Dawn.